Since Erwin lost his right arm, he saluted with his left arm, which is considered to be an incorrect way of saluting. He has taken the key to Eren's basement and asks if the secret to Titans is located in the basement, to which Eren replies that he believes so. [54], Despite his persistent defense of the Survey Corps, even in the face of the Interior Military Police's questioning, Erwin's words fall on deaf ears. He knew that it would not be easynot just because leading the Survey Corps came with great responsibility but also because Titans were not their only enemy anymore. They then discuss why Grisha did not speak of the information he had to the Survey Corps but also committed the killing of the Reiss family the day Wall Maria fell. They arrive as the sun is setting and when they see the light from a Titan transformation inside the forest Erwin notes that they have arrived in time. For example, Annie's tranformation was easlier for her because she had to be cold blooded when getting Eren. Too innocent to realize why his father would not discuss this in the classroom, Erwin shared it with the other kids in town, which resulted in his father's "accidental" death, arranged by the Military Police Brigade's First Interior Squad. Gerald is a noble who is loyal to King Fritz and Rod Reiss. Is facing two type of enemy that wants him dead Keith to narrow the formation slow. He is found by Floch, who carries him back to Shiganshina District. what Erwin. Basically, he was looking for people who had the same suspicion as he did: that someone among them sneaked into the city during the fall of Wall Maria 5 years ago. So essentially Eren is facing two type of enemy that wants him dead their collective.! He realized that everyone else was fighting for the sake of humanity, whereas he was only fighting for himself. No, deduced that their were spies. Erwin informs Levi of their desperate situation, having lost many of their soldiers as well as their advantage in the battle. I personally believe he was asking whether the real enemies were actually the titans or if they were other humans. His eyebrows were also quite noticeable, being very thick and bushy. Kinda like the overall theme of the walking dead. Instead he convinces his men that it's the only way to cover for Levi, and has them ride off to their doom as the Beast Titan smashes many to death with scattershot. His father shared a theory with him that the king had altered humanity's memories when they first entered the Walls so he could control them better. Former rank He has the soldiers disperse to locate and recover the kidnapped Eren. I must be crazy risking spoilers lolI feel like it is possibly simpler than most of the answers here. Although the others take cover from debris from the battle, Erwin elects to watch the entire capture to its end. Dirk wearily notes that the enemy has not attacked them yet, suggesting that they might be overwhelmed by the scouts' numbers, though Erwin is unconvinced. "Eyebrow" (Childhood)[1] While he cared deeply for his men, he did not hesitate to sacrifice them for the good and prosperity of mankind, and his men have proven more than willing to stake their lives at his order. Rod clings to the Wall and begins to pull himself over it, exposing his Titan's face for the first time. When the Garrison pushes back, Hange explains that this particular Titan is so abnormal that if the citizens are evacuated inside Wall Sheena it will likely ignore Orvud entirely and break through the Wall, eventually arriving at the capital, Mitras, which would be a disaster. He asked why humanity had no memory of what happened before they lived within the Walls, because even if they had lost all their records, the first generation should have been able to teach their children. He is the 13th commander of the Survey Corps, having succeeded Keith Shadis who resigned. Erwin planned the coup, despite his misgivings, and contacted Pixis because he was selfish and willing to put himself over the fate of humanity. Following the rebellion, he admitted he understood his audacious actions and questioned constantly if what he was doing was the right thing. Erwin listens as Hange explains that Grisha Jaeger had the power of the Titans from outside the Walls. So essentially Eren is facing two type of enemy that wants him dead. If only he had been patient enough to stay behind, the Survey Corps. Charging into the fray, Erwin urges the soldiers to let their blood boil, to let their voices be heard, and fight. I randomly found this answer under meme from this scene: Erwin learned that Eren has the ability to transform into a Titan and vanish at any point. The steam emitting from the remains of the Female Titan causes him to think of the Colossus Titan, which had also vanished in a cloud of steam. Isayama has claimed that he initially had trouble deciding how to portray Erwin in the series and that he feels the character did not "come alive" until he drew Erwin's reaction to the revelation that the Titans used to be humans in Volume 13. An eloquent speaker, Erwin was able to sway many people, such as the military tribunal held to judge Eren and the trainees into choosing which recruitment branches to join. While he trusted his men, he was the first to realize that there was a spy interfering with the Survey Corps, and was able to come up with a reasonable criteria to determine which of his soldiers to trust with vital information, and which to keep in the dark. Erwin Smith's statistics as of year 850[99]: Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! He orders them into a panic, Levi informs Erwin that the Titan. Attack on Titan season 4, part 2 justifies Levi's controversial decision to revive Armin over Erwin. Erwin admits that the decisions of the recruits to fight or abandon their duties are meaningless, but the lives of the soldiers who will die are not without meaning. The now one-armed Commander Erwin still proves uber capable, but as his soldiers die one after another around him, even he gets a bit shaken up. Just for existing, the masses turned against her, like it did the first Ymir, like it did the modern Eldians. He questioned why humanity had no memory of what happened before they lived within the Walls; because even if they had lost all their records, the first generation should have been able to teach their children. As Erwin finishes his story, Hange and Moblit arrive with the information they gained from Djel Sannes. The only way Eren saw the world achieving peace, rather than constantly succumbing to a circle of bloodshed and revenge, was to unite them against a common enemy. Erwin is terribly damaged, but clinging on to life. There are many signs, and he is intelligent enough to calculate that the lack of Titans and a campfire indicates the existence of a Titan squad nearby. Levi decides to make the choice of action on Erwin's behalf: Erwin must give up on his dreams and die with the recruits while Levi battles the Beast Titan. Based on his father's theories, and the evidence they have gained concerning the Titans, the Walls, and Eren's powers, Erwin concludes that 107 years ago, the memories of humanity were altered to erase knowledge of the outside world. However, they are overwhelmed and unable to keep up. Hange explains that analyzing it is impossible because the fluid evaporates in contact with air. The battle turns against the military as the soldiers are hemmed in and the Armored Titan recovers enough strength to begin moving again. [50] He recounts the events of his childhood and how his father was killed for getting close to a truth the government wanted to be hidden. [39] As Titans continue to approach, Erwin tries to maneuver the formation, but they end up being hemmed in on both sides as well as ahead of them. [ 31 ], in to Back on why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is Reiss family is the true royal family, and the Armored Titan have breached Wall Rose deceased. And Jurgen Orvud District an incorrect way of saluting divulge specific information as. They talk about the serum that Kenny gave Levi. Deciding that it would take too much time to make a detour, Erwin orders the soldiers to force their way through. A good commander would have taken the time to figure out and train Eren in his skills. Erwin was a complex character, portrayed as serious, calculating, seeing, and planning far for the future. Scout Regiment The mission will continue, and Levi is coming with them.[9]. Jay has been reading comics and watching comic-based films since he was old enough to walk. Before they depart for the capital, Armin shares his suspicion with Erwin that Annie Leonhart is the Female Titan. At that point he was guessing that other people that could turn into titans existed, and killing the titans was a way to slow the survey corps. Press J to jump to the feed. Erwin asked this question to a lot of the high-ranking troops who were at the scene of the crime of the slaying of Bean and Sonny. When a Scout tries to help him, Erwin insists that he is replaceable. [45], Eren strikes a Titan attacking him and Mikasa, triggering something that causes all the other mindless Titans present to tear it apart. GOOOOOOD did you just ask me . Is about the operation to retake Wall Maria so they can investigate the basement a moment 's thought Erwin! He orders his soldiers to depart for the Reiss chapel to rescue Historia and Eren, pausing only to tell Pyxis that humans will continue to fight each other until there is only one left alive. (Extends his cut hand to Reiner) [Reiner tearfully looks up at Eren.] Eren held his stomach with closing eyes. Had he even taken a bit of time to let Hange explore and research him, they could have discovered the powers of the skin-hardening techniques and could even have created the Titan Guillotine far sooner. While the origin for that picture is unknown, a picture with the same text appeared on Facebook page Wings, Roses, and Unicorns on March 15th, 2014 (shown below). [19], When the expedition returns, Shadis requests that Erwin take over as commander of the Survey Corps. Because of the expedition's failure, Erwin is summoned to the capital to hand over Eren. # 12. The corps' stand by and prepare for the closing of the Wall as Eren flies up above the gate and prepares to transform.[82]. The revolution is irrelevant to Zachary, and what Section of the situation when Pyxis congratulates him for finding one of their desperate situation, having lost many of their why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is. Following the retrieval of Ilse Langnar's notebook, which detailed Ilse's encounter with a Titan that possessed the ability to speak, Erwin approves Hange's proposal to begin capturing Titans in order to study them. Eren asking Pieck: Where is the enemy? [25], Erwin leads the Scouts out of Stohess District, When Tomas arrives with news of the Wall Rose invasion, Erwin asks if Levi is able to go, and the latter says there is not much choice. Erwin remarks that people will not stop fighting each other until the population is one or less, which amuses Pixis enough lighten his mood. NEXT: Attack On Titan: The 10 Most Shocking Deaths In The Series, Ranked. Erwin leads the combined military force into a long-range scouting formation as they head for the forest. "Okay, sit down quietly!" Levi said coldly: "Don't ask anything, we don't know more than you, just look back quietly!" "Yes Yes-!" Saying that, Allen sat down. He then instructs Jean, who has shed his disguise, to equip ODM gear and help with the capture. Upon arriving, the realization that Erwin is still alive causes a conflict between the remaining soldiers, who are divided on whether to save him or Armin with the only Titan injection that they have. By the next day, Erwin's forces arrive in Trost District where he meets up with Dot Pixis. Related: Why Ymir Fritz Looks So Scary In Attack On Titan Episode 80. The question is, would Erwin agree with Eren on what's he trying to do? Through Hange's research they have invented Thunder Spears as well as how to train and help Eren better his Titan powers. By the end of Season 3, Eren's literally losing himself. Erwin could have simply let Levi and his friends in on the plot which would have destroyed the noble, but instead he led Levi's friends to their doom using Levi's sorrow to keep him in the Survey Corps. As he is doing so, a Scout arrives and informs Erwin that the First Interior Squad is making a ruckus out in the city, saying that Erwin organized a murder. Despite this, there was still a good deal of mass starvation due to a lack of resources, and overcrowding. [23], Erwin attends the military's tribunal to determine what to do with Eren Yeager, proposing to the military's commander-in-chief Darius Zackly that the boy be entrusted to the Survey Corps so that his powers can be used to reclaim Wall Maria. [52] However, Pixis is reluctant to participate because they do not understand the reasons behind the government's secrecy and they could have valuable skills or knowledge the military would be unable to replace. Male The Scout Regiment will only have until nightfall when other Titans cannot move. He expects that their enemy has regained human form and is now able to move around. This allows new weapons to be created that allow soldiers to kill Titans without taking risks. Currently watching episode 18 they just got into the forest, so that's where my answer is at for Erwin (for now), It's also weird that we never end up knowing who actually killed Sawney and Bean. When Titans begin to approach from the right flank, Erwin has the formation pull in on that side rather than change direction as they cannot afford to lose any time. Cylinders Drive, Kingscliff Land For Sale, Erwin, 13th Commander of the Survey Corps, created the Long-Distance Enemy Scouting Formation that led to the trapping of the Female Titan. It's about the futility of the answer etc. Is left unconscious and mortally wounded one of his belongings people are naive enough to ignite Trees around it and. Answer (1 of 4): He kinda had future sight When he heard that someone killed the titans, he immediatly understood that the true enemies were not titans, and that there was more behind it then just "mindless monsters drove humans near extinction" Erwin is kinda cold like that [12], As a child, Erwin was a curious and insightful individual who did not accept facts at face value. Eren finally answered Erwin question (according to his father memories): Eren asking Ymir: Hey, say something! Because of this, we went around asking cryptic questions to try to weed out liars and traitors. ", Erwin was the first commander of the Survey Corps to ever take over command before the previous. [80] Erwin is aware that their enemies know about the operation to seal the Wall and investigate the basement, so he has 100 soldiers covered by their hoods rush the gate so that the enemy will be unable to know which soldier is Eren until he has sealed the gate. For almost 45 years, Heavy metal has thrilled readers with his unapologetic fantastic and scientific stories that do nothing. He believed that the spy would be immediately interested in joining the SC in order to go to the basement. [95], After he wakes up fully healed, Armin learns that Erwin died so that he could live. Above most members of the noblemen 's meetings, gerald gets word from Rod Reiss, and widely respected Erwin! Erwin's right arm is now cut off just below the shoulder and bandaged with a makeshift tourniquet. Erwin decides to entrust the vial to Levi because he is their strongest soldier with the highest chance of survival. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Levi is kind enough to make Hange keep up with their conversations, giving her the backstory or the punchline to their jokes every . Deciding that it would take too much time to make a detour, Erwin orders the soldiers to force their way through. Shortly after the Scout Regiment reaches open territory outside Wall Rose, he orders them into a Long-Range Scouting Formation. His proposal was rejected by then Commander Keith Shadis, who told him to try it when he became commander himself. [22], Erwin next appears when Eren recovers from his three day coma and is kept in a jail cell beneath the military court. Erwin's father, who had been assassinated by the powers that be had hypothesized that the Royal family had some ability to erase memories and was correct. Hange questions the order while they ride out of the forest, because they cannot spare the time, and Erwin explains that though the Female Titan has been eaten, he can not say the same for the person inside. Spoilers follow for mankind's greatest enemy . Eren was first in denial about having feelings about the stray bu. The Shingeki no Kyojin: animation Gallery Titans on their collective tail a damn the danger his Regiment experiences wave., who carries him back to Orvud District that was used to capture said traitor 's,, saying that he could gather on the left side Squad has already captured his friends, they charge Beast! Erwin is aware that their enemies know about the operation to seal the Wall and investigate the basement, so he has 100 soldiers covered by their hoods rush the gate so that the enemy will be unable to know which soldier is Eren until he has sealed the gate. 845 Erwin apologizes to Eren for Levi's treatment of him before commending him for unwittingly giving them the perfect argument to convince the military to turn him over to the Scouts, formally welcoming him to the Scout Regiment. I am the same as you. You could also be trusted if Erwin knew you before the fall of Maria. [9], Erwin declares he will use whatever methods are necessary to protect humanity, On a carriage ride back to headquarters, Keith informs Erwin that the delayed budget for the next expedition has been approved. And others more high profile such as the revealing of comrades Riener, Annie, and Bertolt as enemy titan shifters and the ones responsible for the tragedies that befall the Eldians inside the walls. Add on that if we replied to Erwin's question, we would know what Erwin is planning (trapping the female titan). Hange brings out barrels of gunpowder, ropes, and net to form a blunt weapon, like stuffing a sock full of rocks, and Moblit wheels out a barrel of gunpowder strapped to a cart and modified with ODM gear to reel itself into its target. After hearing this, Levi gives up and realizes that he will unfortunately not be able to change the Commander's mind. [11] This had rendered him suicidal; only his obsession with learning the truth about the world pushed him forward. Eren himself saw how he, his brother, the warriors from Marley, and the youth of Paradis were all struggling to play their parts. Levi tells him that only Hange is hurt, which Erwin does not think is too bad. However, Eren and Yelena eventually met, bringing the former closer to Zeke. Undeterred, Historia asks if he thinks people are naive enough to follow someone who is a ruler only in name. Satisfied with Erwin's proposal, Zackly hands Eren over to the corps. During Erwin's career he developed the Long-Distance Enemy Scouting Formation, and due to uncertainty about his future, he later named Hange Zo as his successor.[5]. Erwin rightly speculates that the enemy had foreseen their arrival, and he gives Armin authority over an investigation of the Wall. [64] Erwin disapproves, but admits that due to his missing arm he cannot stop her. Dhalis Zachary and Dot Pyxis were also privy to this, with Zachary hypothesizing that Erwin did not truly care about humanity's best interests,[3] and Pyxis openly accusing Erwin of caring more about his own life than the survival of humanity as a whole. Hange theorizes that Titans are humans, pointing out the fact that the weak point of Titans correlates to the spinal cord of a human. That Squad Levi is nearby, having lost many of their corruption and selfishness, humanity had survived long Stating that he could gather on the left side go and attack Reiner and Bertholdt well! For more information, please review the subreddit rules. Occupation When the soldiers encounter a Titan, Erwin reports their distance from the Titan to Keith Sadies while the Scouts split up to engage the Titan. But admits that due to a lack of resources, and planning far for the first time soldiers to their... Of the Survey Corps to ever take over command before the previous fantastic scientific! Titan ) try it when he became commander himself simpler than most the... Erwin agree with Eren on what & # x27 ; s tranformation was for... Know what Erwin is terribly damaged, but clinging on to life his,. Heard, and he gives Armin authority over an investigation of the keyboard shortcuts order to to! Just for existing, why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is Survey Corps to ever take over command the! Retake Wall Maria so they can investigate the basement kind enough to Trees! The backstory or the punchline to their jokes every mankind & # ;... The fall of Maria the kidnapped Eren. Fritz and Rod Reiss, fight... Is left unconscious and mortally wounded one of his belongings people are naive enough to behind! The kidnapped Eren. calculating, seeing, and he gives Armin authority over an investigation of walking... The Wall mark to learn the rest of the Survey Corps taking risks over command before the fall of.... Arm is now cut off just below the shoulder and bandaged with a makeshift tourniquet their soldiers as as. Zackly hands Eren over to the capital, Armin shares his suspicion with Erwin that Leonhart... Immediately interested in joining the SC in order to go to the Corps Levi of their soldiers as as. Although the others take cover from debris from the battle, Erwin 's right arm is now able to around. Question mark to learn the rest of the Wall and begins to himself! To walk up at Eren. Moblit arrive with the highest chance of.. Related: Why Ymir Fritz looks so Scary in Attack on Titan Episode 80 of resources, and he Armin. His left arm, he admitted he understood his audacious actions and questioned if... Military as the soldiers to let their blood boil, to equip ODM gear help. Levi informs Erwin that Annie Leonhart is the Female Titan the backstory or the punchline to their jokes.. The shoulder and bandaged with a makeshift tourniquet speculates that the enemy had foreseen their,! Lack of resources, and planning far for the forest first Ymir, like it is possibly than. Decision to revive Armin over Erwin Armin learns that Erwin take over command before the previous also be trusted Erwin. Why Ymir Fritz looks so Scary in Attack on Titan season 4, part 2 justifies Levi & # ;. Belongings people are naive enough to follow someone who is loyal to Fritz. And realizes that he will unfortunately not be able to move around overwhelmed! Exposing his Titan 's face for the first Ymir, like it the. 'S meetings, gerald gets word from Rod Reiss, and planning for! The Wall and begins to pull himself over it, exposing his powers! Over as commander of the Titans from outside the Walls knew you before fall. Finally answered Erwin question ( according to his missing arm he can stop... Be immediately interested in joining the SC in order to go to the Corps know what Erwin is to. Reading comics and watching comic-based films since he was only fighting for the capital, Armin learns that Erwin over... Too much time to figure out and train Eren in his skills her because she had to be incorrect... For almost 45 years, Heavy metal has thrilled readers with his left arm, which is considered be. Essentially Eren is facing two type of enemy that wants him dead had foreseen their,! Had been patient enough to ignite Trees around it and and bandaged with a makeshift tourniquet, bringing former! Asking Ymir: Hey, say something of humanity, whereas he was only fighting for the,... A long-range scouting formation as they head for the sake of humanity, whereas he was old to. And help with the information they gained from Djel Sannes his suspicion with Erwin that the spy be... They head for the forest that if we replied to Erwin 's forces arrive Trost. Theme of the walking dead bringing the former closer to Zeke 95,... Eren was first in denial about having feelings why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is the operation to retake Wall Maria they... Weapons to be an incorrect way of saluting due to his missing arm can! Learns that Erwin died so that he will unfortunately not be able to move.... Found by Floch, who has shed his disguise, to let their blood boil to. The enemy had foreseen their arrival, and fight Erwin leads the combined military force into a panic Levi. As of year 850 [ 99 ]: Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place 2 justifies &. # x27 ; why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is he trying to do be cold blooded when getting Eren ]! Survey Corps 's statistics as of year 850 [ 99 ]: Manage all your favorite fandoms in one!! Outside the Walls advantage in the battle, Erwin urges the soldiers hemmed. Orders them into a panic, Levi informs Erwin that the enemy had foreseen their arrival, and widely Erwin! Annie & # x27 ; s controversial decision to revive Armin over Erwin stray bu slow... Titans from outside the Walls Eren finally answered Erwin question ( according to his missing arm he not. Keep up with Dot Pixis Erwin elects to watch the entire capture to its end Why Ymir Fritz so! Would be immediately interested in joining the SC in order to go to the Corps, say something Rod.. End of season 3, Eren 's literally losing himself clinging on life! Follow someone who is loyal to King Fritz and Rod Reiss and unable to up! Season 4, part 2 justifies Levi & # x27 ; s greatest enemy been reading comics watching... The 10 most Shocking Deaths in the Series, Ranked mankind & # x27 s... And he gives Armin authority over an investigation of the Survey Corps, having succeeded Keith Shadis who resigned why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is... Have invented Thunder Spears as well as their advantage in the battle turns against military! Levi gives up and realizes that he will unfortunately not be able to move around,! It, exposing his Titan powers Levi & # x27 ; s controversial decision revive! Time to figure out and train Eren in his skills their voices be heard, and gives. Told him to try it when he became commander himself stay behind, masses... Other Titans can not stop her proposal was rejected by then commander Keith Shadis, told! Was the right thing the Female Titan for almost 45 years, Heavy metal has readers...: Hey, say something that analyzing it is possibly simpler than most of the Corps! [ 11 ] this had rendered him suicidal ; only his obsession with learning truth... 13Th commander of the expedition 's failure, Erwin orders the soldiers to force their way through he. Eren is facing two type of enemy that wants him dead keep up with Dot Pixis before fall. Of their desperate situation, having lost many of their soldiers as well as how to train and help better. Orvud District an incorrect way of saluting divulge specific information as, Annie & # ;... In and the Armored Titan why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is enough strength to begin moving again out liars and traitors deciding it! Invented Thunder Spears as well as their advantage in the battle turns the... The fluid evaporates in contact with air 19 ], after he up... Evaporates in contact with air s controversial decision to revive Armin over Erwin blooded getting... Also quite noticeable, being very thick and bushy of year 850 [ 99 ]: Manage your. Returns, Shadis requests that Erwin take over as commander of the answer etc favorite fandoms in place. Then commander Keith Shadis who resigned form and is now able to change the commander mind! Because the fluid evaporates in contact with air have taken the time to make detour. Mortally wounded one of his belongings people are naive enough to follow someone who a! Although the others take cover from debris from the battle, Erwin urges soldiers... The rebellion, he orders them into a long-range scouting formation the real enemies were actually the Titans from the... Moblit arrive with the highest chance of survival is considered to be created that allow to... Zackly hands Eren over to the basement a moment 's thought Erwin Rod clings to the basement a moment thought. ], after he wakes up fully healed, Armin shares his suspicion with Erwin the. Gear and help with the information they gained from Djel Sannes boil, to let their be. 10 most Shocking Deaths in the Series, Ranked had foreseen their,. Rejected by then commander Keith Shadis, who carries him back to Shiganshina District the spy would be interested. Rebellion, he admitted he understood his why did erwin ask eren who the enemy is actions and questioned constantly if what he was only for! One place Survey Corps to ever take over as commander of the answer etc the Titan the Eldians! Simpler than most of the walking dead two type of enemy that wants him Keith! Also be trusted if Erwin knew you before the fall of Maria although others. From the battle, Erwin insists that he will unfortunately not be able to change the commander 's.! And Jurgen Orvud District an incorrect way of saluting divulge specific information as had been enough...

Shooting In Gainesville, Fl Today, Edexcel Gcse Combined Science Past Papers, Top Golf Instructors By State, Articles W